Free printable discussion questions

Book Club Questions for spies, lies and alibis

spies, lies and alibis by Natalie Walters

Use these 24 free questions to start a thoughtful book club or small-group conversation. They are arranged in the same 8-session order as the complete guide, which includes 64 questions in all.

Get the complete guide — $29

Week 1

Before the Story Begins — Setting the Stage

Read the cover copy, any front matter, and Chapters 1–3 of Spies, Lies, and Alibis.

  1. 1.The novel's title — Spies, Lies, and Alibis — sets up a world where almost no one is exactly who they appear to be. Before you've read far, what does that title make you expect? How do those expectations shift once you meet Cybil and Ben separately for the first time?

  2. 2.Cybil is described as hiding behind a "polished, professional facade" as an executive assistant. In these opening chapters, what specific details does Walters give us that hint she is far more capable — and far more conflicted — than her job title suggests?

  3. 3.Ben is introduced as a man living entirely under an alias, posing as a financial advisor for the corrupt wealthy. What does it do to a person, do you think, to spend extended time pretending to be someone they're not? What early clues does Walters give us about the toll his undercover life has taken on Ben?

    a.How does he interact with the people around him in those early scenes?

    b.Is there a moment where the mask slips, even briefly?

Week 2

Double Agents of the Heart — Chapters 4–8

Read Chapters 4–8 of Spies, Lies, and Alibis.

  1. 1.Walters uses dramatic irony as a primary engine of tension: we the readers know that both Cybil and Ben are on the right side of the law, but they don't know that about each other. How does that gap in information shape the way you experience their scenes together? Is it more funny, more painful, or more nerve-wracking — and does that shift as the chapters go on?

  2. 2.Ben's internal monologue wrestles with whether Cybil is "an innocent caught in the crossfire or a willing accomplice." What specific behaviors or observations lead him to doubt her? Are his suspicions reasonable given what he knows, or does he let his complicated feelings cloud his professional judgment?

  3. 3.Cybil, for her part, sees Ben as a man whose "motives are deeply suspect." How does she try to gather intel on him without blowing her own cover? What does the cat-and-mouse dynamic between two people who are secretly on the same team reveal about how mistrust works — in fiction and in real life?

Week 3

Old Wounds, New Danger — Chapters 9–13

Read Chapters 9–13 of Spies, Lies, and Alibis.

  1. 1.By this section of the novel, we begin to get more concrete details about what actually happened between Cybil and Ben in the past — what broke them apart, and what was left unresolved. What do we learn? Whose account of events, if either, does Walters seem to present as more accurate, and how does she signal that?

  2. 2.Walters draws a parallel between Cybil's professional role — gathering intelligence without being detected — and the emotional strategy she has used her whole adult life: appearing composed and in control while her inner world is much more turbulent. Where do you see that parallel most clearly in these chapters? Is Cybil's emotional guardedness a strength, a wound, or both?

  3. 3.The Lorenzo Ramirez plot escalates in these chapters. How does the increased physical danger change the dynamic between Cybil and Ben? In your experience, does shared danger tend to draw people together or push them further apart — and why?

Week 4

Covers Blown, Walls Up — Chapters 14–18

Read Chapters 14–18 of Spies, Lies, and Alibis.

  1. 1.The novel's central tension is captured in this line: "Their covers are one lie away from blowing wide open." In these chapters, how close does that actually come to happening? What specific moment felt most dangerous to you as a reader — and was the danger physical, professional, or emotional?

  2. 2.Walters has been praised for "gripping twists" by early readers. Identify at least one significant plot turn in these chapters that genuinely surprised you. Looking back, were the clues there all along, or did Walters successfully hide the ball? How does that twist reframe something you thought you understood earlier in the story?

  3. 3.By this point in the story, it becomes increasingly difficult for either Cybil or Ben to compartmentalize their feelings from their mission. How does each character attempt to manage that bleed-over? Who is more successful at it — and is being "successful" at emotional compartmentalization actually a good thing in this context?

Week 5

Trust Fall — Chapters 19–23

Read Chapters 19–23 of Spies, Lies, and Alibis.

  1. 1.At some point in this section, one of the protagonists makes a decision to trust the other — to act as though the other person is an ally rather than a threat — before that trust has been fully earned or verified. Who moves first, and what prompts them to take that leap? What does Walters's handling of that moment say about the nature of trust?

  2. 2.The moment when Cybil and Ben finally begin to understand each other's true identities and missions is one of the novel's most anticipated payoffs. How does Walters handle that reveal? Is it played for comedy, for relief, for tenderness, for all three? Did the moment land the way you hoped it would, or did it surprise you?

  3. 3.Once the professional deception between them begins to dissolve, the personal history rushes back in. How do Cybil and Ben handle the transition from "operational partners who don't quite trust each other" to something more vulnerable? What does each of them have to confess or admit that has nothing to do with the Lorenzo case?

Week 6

The Reckoning — Chapters 24–28

Read Chapters 24–28 of Spies, Lies, and Alibis.

  1. 1.As the plot races toward its climax, how does Walters manage the dual storylines — the criminal investigation and the romantic reconciliation — so that neither one feels like it's being sacrificed for the other? Which thread feels more urgent to you at this point in the novel?

  2. 2.The climax of a romantic suspense novel usually requires the protagonist(s) to face their deepest fear — not just the external villain, but the internal one. What is Cybil's deepest internal fear as these chapters build toward resolution? What is Ben's? How does each one's fear threaten to derail everything they've worked toward?

  3. 3.Walters's book is set in a world of real estate, finance, and high-end philanthropy — spaces where corruption and legitimacy coexist. As the investigation closes in on Lorenzo, what does the unmasking of his operation reveal about how criminal power maintains itself? Does it feel true to life?

Week 7

Covers Off — Chapters 29 Through the End

Read Chapters 29 through the end of Spies, Lies, and Alibis.

  1. 1.How does the resolution of the Lorenzo Ramirez plotline land for you? Does Walters give the villain a fitting end — one that feels satisfying and consistent with the world she has built — or did any part of the resolution feel rushed or convenient? What would you have changed, if anything?

  2. 2.The novel ends with Cybil and Ben having shed their covers and their alibis — both professionally and personally. What does the "real" version of each character look like in the final pages? How different are they from the people we met in Chapter 1?

  3. 3.Walters's book is billed as "clean" romance — the emotional and relational payoff is built on honesty, vulnerability, and chosen commitment rather than physical escalation. How does the final romantic resolution reflect that? What specifically does Walters give us at the end that feels emotionally earned?

Week 8

Review & Reflection — The Whole Mission

Review your notes, journal entries, and any passages you marked across all of Spies, Lies, and Alibis.

  1. 1.Which week's discussion — which section of the novel — hit you hardest or made you think most? Was it the early chapters of mistrust, the pivotal trust-leap in the middle, the climax, or the ending? What does your answer reveal about what you were personally most ready to hear from this story?

  2. 2.How has your understanding of Cybil or Ben changed from the first chapter to the last? Is there a moment when you judged one of them too quickly — only to have Walters prove you wrong? What does that experience of mis-reading a character tell you about how you read people in real life?

  3. 3.The novel uses the spy thriller genre to explore themes of identity, deception, and trust in relationships. If you stripped away all the espionage and the criminal plot, what is the core human story Walters is telling? Is it a story you recognize from your own life or the lives of people you love?

Get the printable Week 1 handout free

Set your first meeting date and we’ll email the Week 1 handout, unlock the rest of the first session, and lay out the full reading schedule.

Checking your access to the other 5 questions…

Need every question and weekly handout?

The complete spies, lies and alibis guide includes all 64 discussion questions, the full 8-session schedule, closing prayers, and printable handouts.

View the complete study guide