Counterfeit Gods by Timothy Keller
Week 1: Introduction — The Idol Factory
Read the Introduction of Counterfeit Gods. Key passages: Genesis 31 (Rachel and the household idols); Ezekiel 14:3; Romans 1:21–25.
Free Week 1 sampleThis is our full Week 1 — no email required.
Get all 9 weeks of Counterfeit Gods for $24.99 · 7-day refund
Before diving into specific idols, Keller lays the theological and cultural groundwork — what idolatry actually is, why every human heart is prone to it, and why this ancient problem is urgently modern.
Discussion Questions
7 questions1.Keller opens by describing what he calls an "idol factory" — the human heart's relentless capacity to take good things and turn them into gods. In your own words, how does he define an idol? How is this definition broader than the common picture of a carved statue?
2.John Calvin's phrase, which Keller borrows, is that the human heart is a "perpetual factory of idols." Does that description feel harsh, accurate, or both? What reaction does it stir in you?
3.Keller distinguishes between "surface idols" (the specific things we want, like money or approval) and "deep idols" (the fundamental drives beneath them, like security or control). Try to identify one surface idol that is active in your life right now.
a.What deep idol might be driving it — comfort, power, approval, or control?
b.How does naming the deep idol change how you think about the surface one?
4.Keller argues that idols don't just distort our relationship with God — they distort our relationships with other people and with ourselves. Where have you seen this ripple effect in real life, either in your own story or in someone you know?
5.The Introduction draws on Ezekiel 14:3, where God warns about people who have "set up idols in their hearts." What does it mean for an idol to be in the heart rather than on a shelf? How does that internal location make idolatry harder to detect?
6.Keller suggests that our culture's therapeutic and self-help approaches to unhappiness often treat symptoms without diagnosing the idolatry underneath. Do you find that critique fair? Where do you see it playing out in popular culture or even in church culture?
7.By the end of the Introduction, Keller promises that dismantling idols is not primarily about self-improvement but about encountering the true God. How does that framing change the stakes of this study for you personally?
Closing Prayer
Lord, we confess that our hearts are restless factories, always producing new substitutes for You. We have taken good gifts — relationships, achievements, security, approval — and quietly asked them to do what only You can do. Forgive us for the idols we know about, and give us eyes to see the ones we don't. As we begin this study, make us honest enough to look at our own hearts without flinching, and confident enough in Your mercy to keep looking. We ask this in the name of Jesus, who alone is worthy of the trust we keep misplacing. Amen.
Get the complete 9-week guide
All 64 questions across 9 weeks, with closing prayers and a downloadable PDF for your group.
One-time purchase · 7-day refund · Covers your whole group