Free sample

Not a Fan by Kyle Idleman

Week 1: Introduction — A Define the Relationship (DTR) Moment

Read the Introduction of Not a Fan by Kyle Idleman. Key passage: Luke 9:23 ("If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross daily and follow me.")

Free Week 1 sampleThis is our full Week 1 — no email required.

Get all 12 weeks of Not a Fan for $24.99 · 7-day refund

Get the Full Guide

Before any chapter challenges us, Idleman asks a single, unsettling question: are you a fan of Jesus, or are you a follower? Sit with that question honestly as you work through these questions.

Discussion Questions

7 questions

1.Idleman opens by describing what he calls a "DTR" — a Define the Relationship conversation. Have you ever had a DTR moment with Jesus, a point where you clearly defined what kind of relationship you actually have with him? Describe it, or describe why it has never happened.

2.The author distinguishes a "fan" as someone who is enthusiastic about Jesus but not committed to him — an admirer rather than a follower. In your own words, what is the sharpest difference between a fan and a follower as Idleman sets it up in the introduction?

3.Idleman suggests that many people sitting in churches every week are fans, not followers — and that they may not know it. How does that claim land with you? Does it feel like an exaggeration, or does it ring true from your own experience of church culture?

4.He points out that Jesus never seems to recruit followers by making the invitation easier — in fact he often makes it harder ("take up your cross daily"). Why do you think Jesus would do that? What does it tell us about what he is really after?

a.Can you think of a specific moment in the Gospels, beyond Luke 9:23, where Jesus seems to deliberately thin out the crowd rather than grow it?

b.What does that pattern suggest about what Jesus values in a disciple?

5.Idleman is honest that he has been a fan himself at certain points in his life, even as a pastor. What does his self-disclosure do for you as a reader? Does it make the book's challenge easier or harder to receive?

6.The introduction frames the whole book as a kind of mirror. What is the most uncomfortable thing you see when you hold up that mirror right now, at the very start of this study?

7.How does the fan/follower distinction connect to the gospel itself — to what Jesus actually accomplished on the cross and what he calls us into? Is following Jesus something you earn, or something you respond to?

Closing Prayer

Lord Jesus, even before we have read very far, we sense that this book is going to ask us hard questions about where we really stand. We confess that it is easier to admire you than to follow you — easier to show up, sing the songs, and nod along than to deny ourselves and pick up a cross. Give us the courage to have a real DTR moment with you — not a polished answer we think you want to hear, but an honest reckoning with who we actually are. We want to be followers, not fans. Begin that work in us now. Amen.

Get the complete 12-week guide

All 85 questions across 12 weeks, with closing prayers and a downloadable PDF for your group.

One-time purchase · 7-day refund · Covers your whole group

Get the full Not a Fan guide

$24.99· one-time · 7-day refund

Unlock