The Problem of Pain by C.S. Lewis
Week 10: Chapter 9 — Animal Pain
Read Chapter 9 of The Problem of Pain. Key biblical background: Romans 8:19–22; Psalm 104; Job 39–41.
Lewis tackles what many consider the hardest version of the problem of pain: the suffering of animals, who are innocent, have no souls in the traditional sense, and cannot be 'improved' by their suffering. His answers here are more tentative — and that tentativeness is itself instructive.
Discussion Questions
7 questions1.Lewis says animal pain is, in some ways, a harder problem than human pain. Why? What makes it resist the explanations he has already offered for human suffering?
2.He carefully examines what we actually mean when we say an animal is 'suffering' — distinguishing between sentience (awareness of sensation), experience (a continuous self that suffers over time), and consciousness (awareness of oneself as suffering). Why do these distinctions matter, and do you think Lewis is right to apply them to animals?
a.If animals lack a continuous 'self' in Lewis's sense, does that diminish the moral weight of their pain, or does pain simply hurt regardless of who has it?
b.How do these distinctions compare to contemporary animal-cognition research? Does updated science change Lewis's argument significantly?
3.Lewis raises the speculative possibility that Satan, or some malevolent spiritual force, may be responsible for animal suffering before the Fall — suggesting that the natural world itself has been subjected to a kind of corruption from outside. How do you respond to this suggestion? Is it helpful, unhelpful, or simply speculative?
Closing Prayer
Full guideGet the Complete 13-Week Study Guide
All 91 discussion questions, weekly reading schedule, closing prayers, and a downloadable PDF for your group.
Get Your Guide — $24.99