The Problem of Pain by C.S. Lewis
Week 2: Chapter 1 — Introductory
Read Chapter 1 of The Problem of Pain. Key biblical background: Romans 8:18–25; Job 38–39.
Lewis opens not with an argument but with an atmosphere — the vast, indifferent cosmos — and asks how any honest person could see in it the hand of a loving God. Sit with that picture before you move to his answer.
Discussion Questions
7 questions1.Lewis reconstructs the atheist's argument from pain with surprising sympathy, saying it is the argument that once convinced him. In your own words, what is that argument? Why does Lewis think it is so powerful?
2.He describes the universe as a place of 'ruthless indifference' — vast, cold, and dangerous — and asks how anyone could infer a benevolent Creator from such a place. How do you personally respond to that picture of the cosmos? Does it resonate, or does it feel overstated?
3.Lewis introduces the concept of the 'numinous' — Rudolf Otto's idea of a sense of the holy or the uncanny that humans universally experience. How does Lewis distinguish the numinous from mere danger or fear? Why is this distinction important to his argument?
a.Can you think of a time you experienced something you might describe as 'numinous' — not just frightening, but awe-inducing in a way that felt like encounter?
b.Lewis says the numinous is always attached to a 'Presence,' not just an experience of power. How does that distinction set up his later argument?
Closing Prayer
Full guideGet the Complete 13-Week Study Guide
All 91 discussion questions, weekly reading schedule, closing prayers, and a downloadable PDF for your group.
Get Your Guide — $24.99