Lewis calls forgiveness 'the most unpopular of Christian virtues' — and his treatment of it is one of the most honest and surprising in the book.

Discussion Questions

6 questions

1.Lewis begins by saying forgiveness sounds fine in the abstract until you actually have someone to forgive — a neighbor who has wrecked your life, a nation that has done monstrous things. How does his opening move the discussion out of the theoretical and into the real?

2.He unpacks the commandment 'love your neighbor as yourself' and points out that we actually do bear a kind of love for ourselves even while knowing our own flaws. We hate our own sins but still wish good for ourselves. What does this suggest about what forgiving others actually requires?

a.Is there someone you find genuinely hard to forgive? How does Lewis's framing help or complicate that?

b.Lewis says we can hate the sin while loving the sinner — because we already do this with ourselves. Is this distinction real in practice, or does it collapse under pressure?

3.Lewis addresses forgiveness of nations and enemies, noting that Christians are not required to approve or excuse what they have done — only to wish them well, including their repentance and punishment where deserved. How does this distinguish forgiveness from either sentimentality or moral indifference?

4.He writes famously that he had to face the prospect of forgiving the Germans during WWII — this was not theoretical for him. How does the historical context of the book shape the weight of what he is asking?

5.Lewis connects forgiveness to humility: it requires truly believing that I am also a sinner who needs forgiveness, not a good person dealing with a bad one. How does the gospel (specifically, the awareness of our own guilt) make forgiveness possible in a way it can never be on purely humanistic grounds?

+ 3 more questions in this week

Get all 176 questions across 29 weeks

Get Full Guide — $24.99