Lewis now addresses the second and deeper sense of faith — not as holding on, but as the great surrender that changes everything.

Discussion Questions

6 questions

1.Lewis distinguishes between faith as intellectual assent and faith as the total self-surrender he describes here. Why does he say that the virtuous pagan (someone who works very hard at being good) may actually be further from salvation than someone who knows they cannot manage it at all?

2.He describes the experience of coming to the end of your moral effort — realizing that trying your hardest has still left you far short. What does Lewis say this moment of moral bankruptcy is actually *for*?

a.Have you had a moment of moral bankruptcy — realizing that trying harder was not going to be enough? What came of it?

b.Why is this moment, which feels like defeat, actually the necessary precondition for real transformation?

3.Lewis says that once you genuinely try to be perfect, you discover that you need Christ not just as a teacher or example but as a rescuer. How does serious moral effort lead to grace, rather than away from it?

4.He introduces the paradox that the more truly humble and broken a person is, the more God can do with them — and the more self-sufficient and 'good' a person is, the less there is to work with. How does this invert normal assumptions about who is closest to God?

5.Lewis says that 'God works on a different principle' — he uses broken tools. How does this reframe apparent failure, weakness, and inadequacy in the Christian life?

+ 3 more questions in this week

Get all 176 questions across 29 weeks

Get Full Guide — $24.99