Lewis tackles one of the thorniest practical questions about prayer — if God knows everything, what is the point? — and his answer is characteristically surprising.

Discussion Questions

6 questions

1.Lewis argues that God does not experience time the way we do — he does not live in a 'succession of moments' but sees all moments simultaneously, as we see a landscape spread out before us. How does this resolve the apparent problem of God 'foreknowing' our free choices?

2.He addresses the question: if God already knows what will happen, does prayer change anything? How does Lewis's account of divine timelessness reframe the question?

a.Has the apparent futility of prayer — 'God already knows' — ever weakened your motivation to pray? How does Lewis's response land?

b.Lewis says our prayers are part of the eternal 'landscape' God sees — they really are a cause among causes. Does this make prayer feel more or less meaningful to you?

3.Lewis admits these are deeply mysterious questions and that he is offering a possible model, not a proof. What does his intellectual humility here — offering a model rather than demanding assent — model for how we should hold theological paradoxes?

4.He uses the image of God on a mountain above a road, seeing the whole procession at once, while each traveler sees only the step ahead. How does this image reframe both suffering (we see one piece; God sees the whole) and providence?

5.The chapter also touches on how each individual's prayers get God's full, undivided attention — because God is not 'spread thin' across millions of simultaneous requests. What does this say about your significance to God?

+ 3 more questions in this week

Get all 176 questions across 29 weeks

Get Full Guide — $24.99